Log Cabin Cozy
by Meagan Cassel
[Originally published in the Fall 2026 issue of Mount Gretna Magazine. View the complete issue to experience this story in its original design, along with additional photographs and content.]
Of all the properties they might have admired in Mount Gretna, Roy Thomas and Jennifer Schlener-Thomas always had their eye on one particular Conewago Hill cabin. They never imagined, though, they’d be able to blend their love for Gretna and log homes.
One day in 2015, while they were out on a stroll, a “for sale by owner” sign launched their dream into reality. They bid farewell to their beloved tiny Campmeeting cottage of 20 years and set out across town to make “The Light House” their own.
Originally named for neighborhood developer Samuel Light, the cabin was built in 1946. It was the first structure to take shape on Conewago Hill after the Hotel Conewago was dismantled in 1940.
Four more log-style homes — among others — would follow on the loop overlooking Lake Conewago. Lumber for each was sourced from the chestnut forests in which Gretna was born. Construction followed a devastating tree blight that nearly eradicated the chestnut species.
Roy and Jennifer have sought to preserve this rich architectural legacy while infusing their own mountain style, too. Décor both inside and out — along with the cabin’s new name, “The Moose Den” — is inspired by Hugo, the striking creature who presides over a carved mantle in the great room (read more about Hugo in Gretna Trail Mix on page 30 of our print or digital issue).
Hugo is joined in the heart of the three-bedroom, two-bath home by a grand stone fireplace, expansive ceilings, and an open wooden staircase. This spot embodies the quintessential cozy log cabin vibe, making it one of Roy and Jennifer’s favorites. From here, thoughtful touches carry into every meticulously curated corner of the house.
“My grandparents had a cottage on a lake in the Poconos near where I grew up,” says Roy of his inspiration, “so I was always in the woods.”
Roy’s artistic talent is also on full display; he sketches and designs furniture, then works with carpenters to bring intricate custom pieces to life. The furnishings are complemented by Adirondack pieces that Roy and Jennifer gather on regular visits to the New York mountains.
The couple’s fondness for the outdoors flows into a four-season sunroom, which they outfitted with heat to spend more time reading, puzzling, and enjoying the views year-round.
They’re treated to 1.75 acres of wooded tranquility, most of it natural. A stunning landscaped oasis is carved into both the front and back yards, featuring water and fire features, plus a guest house. This time of year, Roy and Jennifer find it especially peaceful.
“Fall in Gretna, regardless of where you’re living, is such a special time,” Jennifer says. “Up here, it is lovely. You are just in the middle of the season as these leaves are changing and falling. It’s a very different perch from which we can experience the season.”
Roy and Jennifer share that perch with Conewago Hill neighbors they adore, but it’s no question the full town tugs at their hearts.
“I still remember that first time I came to visit and was driving down Pinch [Road] thinking, ‘What am I driving into?’” reflects Jennifer. “Just like we tell visitors, it feels like you’re driving into a fairy tale, especially at dusk when all of those cottages are lit up. It’s such a special place.”
Meagan Cassel is a digital marketer and active volunteer in Gretna. She and her family are blessed to have Roy and Jennifer as wooded backyard neighbors.
